I sit in a cubicle office, surrounded on either side by fake walls that extend just beyond my hand's reach, if I were to extend my arm. The fake walls are light gray, like the chair, like the computer across the desk where a young dark haired woman with a slight Puerto Rican accent sits. On the desk are pictures of her children, who look to be elementary school age: a boy, a girl, smiling. There are pale yellow post-it notes affixed to her side of the artificial wall. She is on the phone as I sit with my envelope stuffed with tax forms, pay stubs, and electric bills after waiting nearly an hour in the waiting room, where I can hear a woman and child giggling and playing. I think, if this were a TV show, the child would be crying: the noise of a baby crying so often accompanies images of poverty. I notice a small tear in my trousers, and think of the many people that sit on this side of the desk: all our backs to the open corridor, the row of ten or so cubicles dotted with people just like me, all holding our little envelopes of evidence: where we live, bills, money in the bank.
I think of how alike and not alike I am to the people on this side of the desk; this is the "wrong side" of the desk. The woman on the phone knows this: she knows my name, my social security number, and the numbers on my W-2 form. Last year I was a few thousand dollars above the poverty limit, that magic number full of stigma and surprise that dictates my eligibility for "assistance." She knows I am single, my first mistake; had I married that curly haired young man instead of pursuing my desire to kiss women my life would be different-very different.
She totals up the money I earned last semester: "It's too much to qualify for any aid," she says. I explain that I knew I wouldn't be teaching over the summer, that I had to plan ahead for the economic drought that settles on the heads of adjunct faculty members in the heat of summer. I am excluded because I planned ahead, something poor folk apparently ought not do, I guess. She says, "You may want to wait and apply for medical assistance after you've been unemployed longer." She offers, "If you just need your annual exam or something, you can wait until you qualify."
By the end of her sentence tears have welled up around my reddening eyes. I am at the only non-profit hospital in Cleveland, and have just been told I do not qualify for assistance. But my body qualifies: at 30 years old, malfunctioning. I am apologizing as she reaches for the box of tissues graciously, expectantly. I understand, I say. I have not had health insurance in ten years, but I've been employed or in school every one of those years. My effort is irrelevant here. I can't help but think I'd be better off getting a "real" job, some nice office work like this woman has.
She is very nice, this woman in the red sweater and tan skirt, and I wonder how many people she must reduce to tears on an average day. In my classes I never make anyone cry, I don't think. To be fair, her kindness prompted the tears, anyway. If she were some rude official like someone at the driver's license bureau, I wouldn't be staring at the gray carpet in her cubicle, drying my eyes, feeling unbalanced. Here I am predictable, soft, like any number of people that sit in this chair at the hospital waiting to be judged, accepted, denied: as routinely as the numbers are called out on the loudspeaker in the waiting room. It's enough to get me to start smoking again. What's the loss? A few years I'll lose anyway by going undiagnosed, untreated. I am not waiting for an "annual." I decide whether or not I can pay for a bone marrow biopsy; it's a question of pragmatics.
Days later I see a TV
Continued from page 1.
I'd like to understand the common fears, promoted by the president's claims about health care rationing. I'd like to hear about his macro level analysis of the situation. I'd like to know why millions of people working without coverage don't count: part-time teachers, cafeteria workers, students, and wage laborers. I'd like to hear the response to us, to our work, to our challenges in making ends meet. I'd like to know if he thinks working at some random, full-time, but minimum-wage job just for insurance is better than doing what I am trained to do as an educator. I'd like to think what I do as a college teacher is meaningful to society, regardless of the stage in my career. I'd like to know why this government supports corporate wealthfare and not individual citizens and why it will consider school vouchers viable and not insurance vouchers. I'm sick of hearing about the imaginary "family of four" that politicians claim to help. Instead I'd like to hear exactly why it's so very acceptable to have socialized defense systems, but not socialized medicine. I'd like to know how the president's ideas about justifiable spending would change if he spent one year without health coverage working 35 hours a week at minimum wage. I'd like to know why so many politicians, busy spinning their indefensible positions and fraternizing with each other, don't include more uninsured people in their conversations about health care policy. I guess I'd settle temporarily for increased attention to the meaning of the terms "representative" and "public servant."
This year it won't matter if a branch collides with my face. It won't matter if I need a biopsy or surgery. What matters to me is the knowledge that I have temporary access to health care. I'm not writing a happy ending here; I cannot ignore the millions whose ranks I will shortly re-join. What's important at the micro level is that my one year of coverage is the result of luck: not skill, merit, or justice. I cannot suppose that "no coverage" does not imply decreased need. I question the logic that only certain types of employment qualify workers for coverage. I question the inflated cost of two-minute consultations, the excessive encouragement of new prescriptions, and so-called "medical information" websites funded by pharmaceutical companies.
Carpooling home from work, a friend asks what it feels like to be insured now after all these years. It is an average, cold, gray January day in Cleveland. I try to think of a descriptive metaphor as we head west on Euclid Avenue, passing abandoned houses, new and gated condominiums, and apartment buildings with boards nailed to all the ground-level windows. We drive past two of the biggest, most successful, competitive hospitals in the nation. I tell her: Having insurance means relief, though it allows for excess. It feels like the difference between going to the grocery store hungry and going when you're full. I can't think of a metaphor to describe the feeling of enough.?
Copyright Off Our Backs, Inc. Jan/Feb 2004
Provided by ProQuest Information and Learning Company. All rights Reserved